A proposal to bridge Toorak Rd for the Outer Circle Rail Trail is back on the agenda and under the wing of Victoria’s Department of Transport. The busy tram route is a major issue for residents using the trail, which is a rail-side path in this area.
People approaching from the north are faced with a pedestrian level crossing, followed by a steep decline to a car park off Toorak Rd. There cyclists are supposed to dismount and walk to a signalised pedestrian crossing to the west, then back on the other footpath to the trail. Naturally, there’ve been some inventive alternative routes created.
The bridge proposal last surfaced in 2018, when the City of Boroondara considered it a good candidate for the Safer Cyclists and Pedestrians Fund. At that stage, the project was estimated to cost $4 million but now that’s up closer to $10 million. The bridge would require considerable nightworks and possible disruption to tram and train services.
Cheaper options include continuing the trail on the eastern side of the Alamein line gradually down to road level and installing an extra signalised pedestrian crossing to get trail users back to the trail on the southern side of Toorak Rd. The department is due to present its final design early in 2023 with work to start in the middle of 2024.
Sunday, 4 June, saw the Mansfield Marathon along the Mansfield end of the Great Victorian Rail Trail (GVRT) return for t...
Paul Baker, an enthusiastic rider who is aiming to ride every rail trail in Victoria in 2023, recently rode his 29th Ra...
The section of the Port Fairy – Warrnambool Rail Trail between Port Fairy and Illowa will soon benefit from a new surf...
The community have the opportunity to provide direct feedback to assist the Mt Alexander Shire Council in partnership wi...
The City of Greater Bendigo will shortly commence a project to construct and install public toilets, bike hoops, new par...
A large crowd turned out today (Friday 26 May) on a beautiful morning at Trawool Estate for the official launch of the A...
On Wednesday 10 May 2023 a public-information session was held for community members to view and discuss the plans for r...
The duplication of Main South Road from Seaford to Sellicks Beach has commenced and will include a 16km off-road shared ...
The Bunny Rail Trail is a new trail under development between Ballarat and Buninyong in Western Victoria. Walkers, runne...
The good news just keeps rolling in for the Tweed Section of the Northern Rivers Rail Trail with the Tweed Council NRRT ...
On 17 May 2023, Cessnock City Council unanimously approved the Review of Environmental Factors (REF) and associated repo...
The third South Burnett Express Rail Trail Relay, run from Kingaroy to Wondai (on the Kilkivan – Kingaroy Rail Tra...
The catchily-named Eastern Dandenong Ranges Trail will have its 800m extension from Edenmont Rd to Belgrave-Gembrook Rd ...
The Coast to Vines Rail Trail in South Australia now has a new side trail called the Flat to Vale Trail and while it is ...
The Australian and South Australian governments have jointly (50:50) funded $400m for the removal of level crossings whe...
The Great Victorian Rail Trail (GVRT) Art Installation Project is on track to be completed by the end of April as planne...
Stay up to date with the latest news about Rail Trails with our free email news.
Register for news updatesSunday, 4 June, saw the Mansfield Marathon along the Mansfield end of the Great Victorian Rail Trail (GVRT) return for t...
Paul Baker, an enthusiastic rider who is aiming to ride every rail trail in Victoria in 2023, recently rode his 29th Ra...
The section of the Port Fairy – Warrnambool Rail Trail between Port Fairy and Illowa will soon benefit from a new surf...
The community have the opportunity to provide direct feedback to assist the Mt Alexander Shire Council in partnership wi...
The City of Greater Bendigo will shortly commence a project to construct and install public toilets, bike hoops, new par...
A large crowd turned out today (Friday 26 May) on a beautiful morning at Trawool Estate for the official launch of the A...
On Wednesday 10 May 2023 a public-information session was held for community members to view and discuss the plans for r...
The duplication of Main South Road from Seaford to Sellicks Beach has commenced and will include a 16km off-road shared ...
The Bunny Rail Trail is a new trail under development between Ballarat and Buninyong in Western Victoria. Walkers, runne...
The good news just keeps rolling in for the Tweed Section of the Northern Rivers Rail Trail with the Tweed Council NRRT ...
On 17 May 2023, Cessnock City Council unanimously approved the Review of Environmental Factors (REF) and associated repo...
The third South Burnett Express Rail Trail Relay, run from Kingaroy to Wondai (on the Kilkivan – Kingaroy Rail Tra...
The catchily-named Eastern Dandenong Ranges Trail will have its 800m extension from Edenmont Rd to Belgrave-Gembrook Rd ...
The Coast to Vines Rail Trail in South Australia now has a new side trail called the Flat to Vale Trail and while it is ...
The Australian and South Australian governments have jointly (50:50) funded $400m for the removal of level crossings whe...
The Great Victorian Rail Trail (GVRT) Art Installation Project is on track to be completed by the end of April as planne...
3 comments on “Outer Circle Bridge Plan”
I agree that a bridge is needed at Toorak Road to provide a high level crossing for Cyclists and Walkers to safely cross Toorak Road but disagree that this should be built on the Western side of the existing railway bridge.
At some point The Outer Circle Rail Trail has to cross the Alamein railway line between Hartwell and Burwood Stations and for the following reasons this would be achieved far more safely by constructing the proposed new Bike Path Bridge and its approaches on the Eastern side of the line.
The existing railway crossing at Fordham Avenue is located approximately half way between the Burwood and Hartwell railway stations where trains are travelling at high speed and where the line is slightly higher than the surrounding ground and with its zig-zag layout this makes it extremely difficult for cyclists (young and old) to negotiate it.
In contrast, there is an existing very easy to use bike & pedestrian level crossing adjoining the northern end of the Burwood Railway Station where trains are travelling at no more than platform speed and would be able to stop in time if someone (again young or old) is caught on the tracks.
This crossing adjoins the Station Carpark on the eastern side of the rail line and extends northwards half way to Toorak Road and one side of this carpark could easily be used the for the Bike Path giving it direct access to the Southern side of Toorak Road.
Using a route through the existing Burwood Station crossing and its eastern Carpark should not be any more expensive and would allow the existing access paths on the Western side of the Rail Line to remain untouched.
It may also avoid some future tragedy at the high speed Fordham Road crossing point.
The elevated bridge is the only option to secure a safe and accessible crossing for the trails' users. The other option mentioned is additional signals 50 metres from the existing signalised crossing at Summerhill Rd. That doesn't qualify as an option merely an unnecessary duplication. It would still leave users making their way through the existing carpark and the existing near impossible climb.
Cost. the $10m is expensive but when amortised over the life of the bridge is well covered by the annual benefit (safety/accessibility). As to the amenity of adjoining (a few only) property owners, there are existing train/tram lines in case you hadn't noticed or heard.
While we're at it, the existing trail terminates at the Gardiners Creek/Malvern Valley GC. The Outer Circle rail line commenced at Hughesdale RS. Some planning should commence to "bridge" the Glen Waverly rail line/Monash Freeway and then Dandenong Rd from its existing terminus to "complete" the trail. The reserves (with their paths) are already there.
This project goes back well before 2018, it was included in the 2008 Boroondara Bicycle Strategy as the preferred long term option for a safe Anniversary / Outer Circle crossing of Toorak Road.
In 2011 the short term option, traffic signals on the east side of Summerhill Road intersection were installed, it is noteworthy that VicRoads deemed installation of traffic signals in line with the shared path were considered too dangerous at that location, yet this is what DOT/VicRoads is now proposing as an alternative to the bridge (the East side solution). At that time the path through Hartwell was designated as a shared path, however, the Hartwell traders decided they did not want to share "their" footpath with cyclists and the shared path status was removed. (Hartwell Traders Assocation was headed up by Bob Stensholt, former member for Burwood)
In 2014 council put the bridge option out for public consultation and it received overwhelming support from the community, that is, all but a small but vocal group of locals whose street backs onto the shared path and includes Bob Stensholt, the former member for Burwood. Council was forced to look at all possible alternatives and in May 2018 reported to council that the bridge was the safest option and sought approval seek funding for it's construction.
There is insufficient land to deliver a DDA path along the DOT's proposed "East side" option, it would require the lengthy and costly land acquisition process, land acquisition was acknowledged in the VicRoads DOT survey.
If the east side option gets up, rather than the bridge, we will be waiting another decade for the land situation to be resolved, with no improvements delivered in that time, in the meantime the cost to deliver the bridge escalates even further putting this safest option further out of reach.
It is also worth noting that signs erected by VicRoads along the shared path alignment, notifying riders of the recent public survey were stelthily removed twice, preventing many path users from having the oportunity to participate in this survey.